A well-known legal battle between the US oil business and environmentalists over regulations that it said might lead to the total suspension of production in the Gulf of Mexico was postponed. Despite an earlier conclusion that agency regulations lacked enough protections for endangered species, a federal judge said Monday that they could be kept in effect until May even though they were scheduled to expire in December. The industry contended that without a successor, the nullification of the US National Marine Fisheries Service's "biological opinion" would leave a void that might stop production and result in the loss of hundreds of thousands of jobs, costing the country's economy $2.8 billion per month. The industry was accused of "fear mongering" by environmentalists, who also warned that the five-month postponement raised the possibility of the extinction of the Gulf of Mexico Rice's whale, whose population has dropped to about 50 individuals. General counsel Ryan Meyers of the industry advocacy group American Petroleum Institute praised what he described as "the court's pragmatic decision." "Today's decision only offers short-term respite; more needs to be done to prevent disruptions to the foundation of our country's energy supply." There was no response from the Fisheries Service. The legal dispute is the most recent in a string of conflicts between environmental organizations and the oil and gas sector, which has cautioned that litigation threatens individual companies, new developments, and the energy security of the United States. The decision on Monday follows a challenge won in August by the Sierra Club and Friends of the Earth, among others, to overturn the current "biological opinion" dictating environmental safeguards required of businesses operating in the Gulf, which accounts for roughly 16% of US petroleum production. According to the National Marine Fisheries Service, a fresh opinion won't be available until May. The oil industry and the agency jointly requested an extension from the court. Chris Eaton, senior attorney at Earthjustice, which filed the lawsuit on behalf of the groups, said, "It's been really frustrating to see the agency delay and then ask for a further delay to protect species.""It's critical to implement safeguards as soon as possible." "This case is about getting some common sense measures to prevent the extinction of a whale, not about shutting down the oil and gas industry," he continued. "We think it's terrible that the industry is reversing course and spreading false information about this."
The environmental group Sierra Club and a number of local organizations filed the lawsuit, claiming the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission did not sufficiently take into account the project's greenhouse gas emissions and neighborhood impact when awarding the permit. NextDecade, whose stock price nearly fell in half after the August decision, has cautioned that the result may establish a precedent that prevents further LNG ventures and other major building projects. The CEO of NextDecade, Matt Schatzman, told the Financial Times that "delays kill infrastructure projects and the opponents of these projects, whether they are LNG facilities or transmission lines crossing state lines, know this."
