India's diversion from cheaper Russian crude will be more than compensated for by gains from anticipated lower U.S. tariffs, Nomura Holdings Inc. said on Friday.
U.S. President Donald Trump has also been repeatedly calling on India to end purchases of Russian oil, and economists Sonal Varma and Aurodeep Nandi argue the shift would pave the way for a trade deal with Washington and a reduction in tariffs.
"Any tariff-cut below ASEAN-average of 19%-20% would help in re-establishing the relative competitiveness of India in labor-intensive exports," the economists have stated. The 25% retaliatory duty on Russian oil imports is likely to be dropped after November, whereas the retaliatory 25% tariff will continue throughout the fiscal year till March.
With the Russian discount for oil below world prices dropped to $1.8–$2.2 a barrel, the immediate impact of such a change would amount to roughly 0.04% of gross domestic product, the report said. It however cautioned that "the indirect effect through higher global oil prices would be more significant to monitor."
Even though the two countries are yet to sign a trade agreement, Indian refiners have indicated that their Russian crude imports will decrease to near zero after U.S. sanctions on crude giants Rosneft PJSC and Lukoil PJSC.
India has imported approximately 1.8 MMbpd of Russian oil imports during the first six months of this year, which accounts for 36% of its foreign exports, as per data from Kpler. The Middle Eastern and American countries will now have to fulfill this need, pushing the price of global energy up as big producers raise prices following the sanctions.
It will also be expensive for India to import the oil from America because of freight costs, IndusInd Bank Ltd. chief economist Gaurav Kapur explained.
"It is not easy to completely shift away from Russian crude after all these years of reliance on it," Kapur added. "The question is of India's energy security and we will have to locate alternative sources of suppliers in a hurry.".
Last week, U.S. President Donald Trump announced India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi had promised the country will no longer buy oil from Russia, but that the switch would be "a little bit of a process." India has yet to reply to the issue.
The inflation impact must be held in check, with the consumer price index currently at below 2%, the lower end of the central bank's target range of 2%-6%. Reserve Bank of India calculations place a 10% hike in crude bill at increasing inflation by about 30 basis points and cutting growth by about 15 basis points, on the assumption of a full pass-through to domestic prices.
