OIL: CURRENT TRENDS
The Permian basin continues to be the most productive oil-producing area in the United States, producing about half of the nation's total oil output. It hit a record of approximately 6.3 MMbpd in 2024. Growth, however, is slowing down. First-quarter 2025 industry expectations are for oil production to grow 250,000 to 300,000 bpd in 2025, versus a 380,000-bpd gain in 2024. This aligns with projections1 of the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) for a moderation from the scorching growth rate of the past several years. The slowdown is a result of geologic limitations, as the best drilling locations (Tier 1 acreage) are increasingly exhausted, and operators shift to less productive fringes. Well productivity is also a problem.
While technological advancement like longer lateral wells (now averaging over 10,000 ft) and hydraulic fracturing has kept production at high rates, per-well productivity has declined in some areas. For instance, in the Delaware sub-basin, newer wells have shown a negative trend2 in the recovery of oil in the period of the last two years, while some stabilization has been felt in the Midland sub-basin. The variability is a function of differences in geology, well spacing and designs completion, with "parent-child" well interference reducing yields in regions of tight drilling. NATURAL GAS DYNAMICS Permian natural gas production keeps growing, in large part as a byproduct of drilling for oil, to a volume of approximately 20.7 Bcfd in early 2025. This expansion is not challenge-free. The gas-to-oil ratio (GOR) has risen from 3,100 cubic ft per barrel (cf/b) in 2014 to 4,000 cf/b in 2024, with gas accounting for a larger percentage of production-at times at the expense of oil profitability.
Infrastructure bottlenecks are also taking a toll. Natural gas takeaway pipeline capacity is hitting its limit, and with maintenance season already underway, prices at the Waha hub in West Texas have dropped, even dipping negative at times.3 This forces operators to flare or shut in wells, thus curbing oil production, since the two are typically co-produced. New pipelines, including the Matterhorn Express (2.5-Bcfd capacity, expected third-quarter 2024) and expansions of the Permian Highway Pipeline (0.55 Bcfd incremental), will alleviate some of these bottlenecks by late 2025. Additional longer-term projects, including the Apex (2.0 Bcfd), Blackcomb (2.5 Bcfd) and Saguaro Connector (2.8 Bcfd) pipelines, expected 2027, could add 7.3 Bcfd of capacity, feeding Gulf Coast LNG terminals and Mexican markets. These other gas infrastructure projects could help narrow the Waha-Henry Hub spread, which hit $3 early in April 2025, and stabilize prices. However, until that capacity is online-likely not until 2026-analysts are warning of a "darker" outlook, with takeaway capacity available shrinking and prices still vulnerable to production spikes and maintenance outages. In the meantime, innovative solutions to these natural gas challenges are being created. Permian's largest independent producer, Diamondback Energy, said in February4 that it is looking for equity partners in a potential new gas-fired power plant to help consume excess gas locally, and thus reduce reliance on pipeline construction. Diamondback would plan to use some of the electricity generated by the plant for its own operations, and sell the rest to new datacenters to be developed in the area.
OPERATIONAL AND ECONOMIC CHALLENGES
Permian operators continue to face rising costs and geological complexities. Drilling in the fringe areas also brings more water-up to four barrels of water for every barrel of oil, compared to a 1:1 ratio in other basins-and the water-to-oil ratio can be as high as 12:1 in some areas.
Chevron, a leading Permian producer, will grow output by up to 10% in 2025 while minimizing capital spending, prioritizing cash flow and shareholder returns over pure volume. ExxonMobil reported in March that it will continue to expand output after its takeover of Pioneer Natural Resources in 2024, a $60 billion deal that greatly enhanced its regional position. The company has already produced over 1.2 MMboed of oil equivalent a day in the Permian in mid-2024 and expects this to grow to around 2 MMboed by 2027.. For 2025 alone, ExxonMobil expects to maintain a path toward this goal using its now-consolidated 1.4 million acres of contiguous acreage-the largest in the basin-to optimize drilling and operational efficiencies.
FEDERAL LEASE SALES IN THE DELAWARE BASIN
Following four years of not adhering to the provisions of the Federal Lands Leasing Act to hold regular oil and gas lease sales, President Trump and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum both promised to rapidly speed up sales of new acreage after their inauguration in January. It is a significant commitment for the southeastern New Mexico portion of the Delaware Basin, where vast fields of federal lands are managed by the Bureau of Land Management.
Burgum followed through on his word in the first quarter of 2025, releasing new leases6 on 34 parcels of land encompassing more than 25,000 acres in the states of New Mexico, Wyoming, Montana, Nevada and North Dakota. " Lease sales today demonstrate Interior's unwavering commitment to advancing American Energy Dominance, and we are grateful to all who develop energy on public land," said Department of the Interior Secretary Doug Burgum. "By building upon the Trump administration's commonsense, pro-growth policies, we're ensuring public lands are being put to their best use to grow national security, economic prosperity and livelihood of the American people." BLM also has a next lease sale for New Mexico acreage planned for May 22. Details on this and other scheduled sales can be found on the DOI.gov7 website. EXTERNAL FACTORS BRING PRICE DESTRUCTION
The industry in the Permian and across the country has always been able to address operational and infrastructure problems through some combination of engineering, technology advancements and business efficiencies. But all too frequently, outside events happen that are outside of the control of company management teams. Consequences from such outside events become amplified when two or more major changes occur simultaneously, as they did in early April.
OPEC+ AGREES TO UNWIND VOLUNTARY PRODUCTION CUTS
The eight OPEC+ member countries, which have been observing voluntary production cuts since November 2023, agreed on April 3 on a "gradual and flexible" rollback of the 2.2-MMbpd cuts over an 18-month period, effective April 1. The scheduled monthly production rise will be 138,000 bpd.
The release also says the eight countries-Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iraq, UAE, Kuwait, Kazakhstan, Algeria and Oman-"will apply a production adjustment of 411 thousand barrels per day, equal to three monthly increments, in May 2025." That's a tremendous initial jolt of additional oil on the market, which put immediate downward pressure on crude prices.
PRESIDENT TRUMP'S MAJOR TARIFF ANNOUNCEMENT
The impact of the OPEC+ move was magnified by the fact that it followed, by less than 18 hours, the April 2 White House Rose Garden event, where President Trump announced a large new round of import tariffs8 on imports from nearly all countries, a move which had an immediate impact on global stock and commodities markets.
Crude oil prices reacted to the Trump tariff announcement in an immediate and dramatic way, with both the international Brent index price and the US domestic WTI price dropping by around 6%9 before trading began on April 3. Both the Brent and WTI prices dropped by around 5% during trading on April 4. Meanwhile, global stock markets witnessed a general sell-off as a reaction to the Trump tariffs, with US markets declining over 10% in the next two trading sessions. Obviously, this kind of continued production growth as is being projected for the Permian basin by the EIA and others cannot be sustained, if crude prices drop down to a lower trading range for an extended period of time. Nevertheless, President Trump and other administration officials, including White House advisor Peter Navarro, have persisted in indicating that they would like to see oil prices drop down to $50/bbl in order to knock out the back of lingering inflation from the Biden administration.
That is concerning, given that the first-quarter 2025 Energy Survey,10 published March 26 by the Dallas Federal Reserve, estimates that drillers in the Permian basin require a $62 oil price, just to break even drilling new shale wells on Tier 1 acreage. That breakeven price rises rapidly as the quality of the drilling prospect falls. Again, as of the date of this writing, conditions affecting the path of crude prices, supply chains, and the overall economy are impossible to predict. However, it appears likely that all those predictions issued during first-quarter 2025 will be revised dramatically in the second quarter.
